Yearly Archives: 2016

Echelon Reference Series Spell Books

Echelon Game Design Logo

News release? New releases? Whatever.

My books, let me sell you them.

It is to my immense satisfaction that I announce that I have completed, for now, the Echelon Reference Series Spell Book line.

They are not yet all published, but all have been compiled and laid out.

Most are already available at OneBookShelf (DriveThruRPG/RPGNow), the rest are being uploaded and scheduled for release, two per week until done… at the end of March.

They are all being uploaded for release at the Open Gaming Store and at Paizo. Because their packaging works differently I might simply do each line of spell books in one step, rather than releasing as I have been at OBS.

Spell Book Description

The full spell book for each spell list (alchemist, bard, cleric/oracle, druid, inquisitor, magus, paladin, ranger, sorcerer/wizard/arcanist, summoner, witch) contains the compiled spell list across all included sources. For the PRD-Only version this includes

  • Pathfinder Roleplaying Game Core Rulebook
  • Pathfinder Roleplaying Game: Advanced Player’s Guide
  • Pathfinder Roleplaying Game: Ultimate Magic
  • Pathfinder Roleplaying Game: Ultimate Combat
  • Pathfinder Roleplaying Game: Advanced Race Guide
  • Pathfinder Roleplaying Game: Advanced Class Guide
  • Pathfinder Roleplaying Game: Occult Adventures

Despite the spell books containing spells from all sources listed above, I have not yet prepared spell books for the Pathfinder Roleplaying Game: Advanced Class Guide classes yet, nor for the classes from Pathfinder Roleplaying Game: Occult Adventures.

The 3pp+PRD spell books contain all of the above, plus spells — thousands of them — from select third-party sources. For Open Game License reasons (product titles are considered Product Identity) I can’t list them as I did the books above (permission granted via the Pathfinder Compatibility License). As the table below shows, this often doubles or triples the number of spells.

Each spell list is split by level, and then by school. While the wizard is really the only class that depends on the school information, splitting by school makes it easier to find spells with similar themes or applications even for other classes. For instance, a cleric interested in protecting others can focus on abjuration spells, while one interested in conquering the realm of undeath might focus on necromancy spells.

The spells themselves are grouped by level and sorted alphabetically. All the first-level spells are together, all the second-level spells, and so on.

Spell Books By Level

The spell books are each released on PDF per spell level, with a compilation at the end. The Bard Spell series starts with a PDF for cantrips, then a PDF for each spell level from 1 through 6, then a compilation with the entire compiled spell list and all seven levels of spells. This was done in part so each could be released in stages, and in part because the compilations can be quite large: ERS Cleric/Oracle Spells (3pp+PRD) is 580 pages, and ERS Sorcerer/Wizard Spells (3pp+PRD) is somewhat over 1,100 pages!

The compilations can be large, but because they involve so little additional work on my part because of how I prepared the smaller PDFs, at OBS I bundle them together: if you have bought the level-specific PDFs, they come off the bundle price and you can get the compilation for free.

Spell Counts by List and Level

The table below shows the number of spells in each list and level.

Spells per Level
Spell List 3pp/PRD 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Total Classes Using Spell List
Alchemist 3pp 92 100 99 77 59 46 473 Alchemist
Alchemist prd 42 58 54 40 23 20 237 Alchemist
Bard 3pp 140 250 277 216 145 118 109 1,255 Bard, Skald
Bard prd 20 82 107 68 50 34 34 395 Bard, Skald
Cleric/Oracle 3pp 128 225 284 264 219 206 143 138 99 107 1,813 Cleric, Oracle, Warpriest
Cleric/Oracle prd 13 62 94 70 60 58 36 25 26 21 465 Cleric, Oracle, Warpriest
Druid 3pp 101 232 262 220 180 153 118 84 72 79 1,501 Druid
Druid prd 14 67 74 64 49 34 32 20 18 18 390 Druid
Elementalist prd 6 15 28 25 24 27 17 13 14 12 181 Elementalist Wizard
Inquisitor 3pp 34 124 137 121 101 72 55 644 Inquisitor
Inquisitor prd 14 65 77 66 52 36 24 334 Inquisitor
Magus 3pp 30 92 101 96 63 49 44 475 Magus
Magus prd 15 58 57 48 32 22 25 257 Magus
Paladin 3pp 117 104 93 106 420 Paladin
Paladin prd 44 46 33 27 150 Paladin
Ranger 3pp 204 149 121 84 558 Ranger
Ranger prd 65 55 41 20 181 Ranger
Sorcerer/Wizard 3pp 229 491 568 534 483 403 318 277 215 208 3,726 Sorcerer, Wizard, Arcanist
Sorcerer/Wizard prd 22 137 163 142 124 102 83 74 49 44 940 Sorcerer, Wizard, Arcanist
Summoner 3pp 39 81 95 100 87 83 83 568 Summoner
Summoner prd 12 37 45 56 52 45 45 292 Summoner
Witch 3pp 123 200 251 221 188 163 142 131 122 109 1,650 Witch
Witch prd 15 83 107 88 70 51 39 40 28 22 543 Witch

Links in the table above:

  • For a specific spell level, takes you to that specific spell lists level’s PDF;
  • For the total, takes you to the compendium of that spell list PDF;
  • For a class name, takes you to the Echelon Reference Series title for that class.

Schedule of New Releases

There are 22 spell books in the table above that have not been released, plus 6 compilations/bundles. They are ready for release, but because of the flooding mechanisms at OBS I’m going to release them two per week until the middle of March.

Release Date Product Code Title
2016-12-12 ers-1612-005 ERS: Cleric/Oracle Spells V
2016-12-15 ers-1612-006 ERS: Alchemist Extracts IV
2016-12-19 ers-1612-007 ERS: Druid Spells V
2016-12-22 ers-1612-008 ERS: Summoner Spells IV
2016-12-26 ers-1612-009 ERS: Sorcerer/Wizard Spells VI
2016-12-29 ers-1612-010 ERS: Bard Spells V
2017-01-02 ers-1701-001 ERS: Cleric/Oracle Spells VI
2017-01-05 ers-1701-002 ERS: Summoner Spells V
2017-01-09 ers-1701-003 ERS: Druid Spells VI
2017-01-12 ers-1701-004 ERS: Sorcerer/Wizard Spells VII
2017-01-16 ers-1701-005 ERS: Cleric/Oracle Spells VII
2017-01-19 ers-1701-006 ERS: Alchemist Extracts V
2017-01-23 ers-1701-007 ERS: Druid Spells VII
2017-01-26 ers-1701-008 ERS: Bard Spells VI
2017-01-30 ers-1701-009 ERS: Sorcerer/Wizard Spells VIII
2017-02-02 ers-1702-001 ERS: Alchemist Extracts VI
2017-02-06 ers-1702-002 ERS: Cleric/Oracle Spells VIII
2017-02-09 ers-1702-003 ERS: Summoner Spells VI
2017-02-13 ers-1702-004 ERS: Druid Spells VIII
2017-02-16 ers-1702-005 ERS: Bard Spells
2017-02-16 ers-1702-006 Bard Spells Compiled [bundle]
2017-02-20 ers-1702-007 ERS: Sorcerer/Wizard Spells IX
2017-02-23 ers-1702-008 ERS: Alchemist Extracts
2017-02-23 ers-1702-009 Alchemist Extracts Compiled [bundle]
2017-02-27 ers-1702-010 ERS: Cleric/Oracle Spells IX
2017-03-02 ers-1703-001 ERS: Summoner Spells
2017-03-02 ers-1703-002 Summoner Spells Compiled [bundle]
2017-03-06 ers-1703-003 ERS: Druid Spells IX
2017-03-09 ers-1703-004 ERS: Sorcerer/Wizard Spells
2017-03-09 ers-1703-005 Sorcerer/Wizard Spells Compiled [bundle]
2017-03-13 ers-1703-006 ERS: Cleric/Oracle Spells
2017-03-13 ers-1703-007 Cleric/Oracle Spells Compiled [bundle]
2017-03-16 ers-1703-008 ERS: Druid Spells
2017-03-16 ers-1703-009 Druid Spells Compiled [bundle]

Off the Path: City Construction, Part 4: Polyhedral Process

In discussing city wards in my last post, I said that each ward could have up to three qualities. This was partly to keep the total number of qualities in a multi-ward settlement to reasonable levels, but also to prepare for this step: applying the polyhedral process (introduced in Polyhedral Pantheons) to settlement design.

It is reasonable to expect that while settlements within a culture will vary, that they will also have some similarity between them. For instance, a militaristic culture could be expected to have that reflected in the settlement scores or in common qualities. Not all settlements will have the same, or even all, qualities that are commonly found, but it’s reasonable to expect that there will be recognizable elements.

Here, it can mean having wards present in multiple settlements with the same qualities. It can help having certain pairs of qualities present, each pair being associated with a different third quality.

In other words, the polyhedral process can be a good fit.

Applying the Polyhedral Process to Settlement Design

Choose twelve qualities (possibly doubling up on some if you want to reinforce them or have them very common). Assign these qualities to the twelve points of an icosahedron (d20). This can be done randomly, deliberately, or a mix of the two (if I want to have Fortified and Religious associated at least once I make sure of that pair, then randomly assign the others).

The Polyhedral Pantheons Worksheets can be handy here. They say ‘pantheon’ and ‘domains’ in the sheets, but the sheets will work with ‘wards’ and ‘qualities’ just as easily.

When you’ve done that, each face of the icosahedron will have three qualities associated via the points of the face. This provides a set of twenty ward configurations that are common across the culture.

Assigning Priority

A later step in the process will involve rolling for wards present in a settlement. You could use the numbers on the faces of the icosahedron, but things will work better if you order the wards from highest priority (i.e. most important or common across the settlements) to lowest (least important or common).

If you want to get really fancy you could assign a prime number to each quality, then multiply the quality values for each face. This will give you twelve unique values that can then be ordered from lowest to highest. The first twelve primes are (2, 3, 5, 7, 11, 13, 17, 19, 23, 29, 31, 37). I’d say this is getting pretty geeky, but you are reading this right now….

In any case, assign the most important or most common ward configurations to the lowest values in a twenty-row table, less common to higher values. This will be useful in the next step.

Ward Selection

Now that you’ve got a table of twenty ward configurations, arranged from most common to least common, grab a number of dice equal to the number of wards you want. I’d start with 1d4, then add 1d6, 1d8, 1d10, 1d12, then as many d20s as are needed (or d4, d8, d12, d20, or d6, d10, d20, etc.). Roll them all at once on a piece of paper, keeping them reasonably close together (I roll them in the lid of an old box set, with a piece of paper in the lid).

This is why you want the most common wards with lower numbers, and less common with higher numbers. The small dice cannot roll high, but all dice can roll low. It is certain that you will end up with at least one die rolling 1..4, quite likely the d6 will roll 1..4, and so on.

If you roll doubles you might change one of them to a different number (bump it to the next higher unassigned number, or next lower unassigned number), or keep the same ward numbers but tweak the quality values — perhaps there are two dockyards, one for commercial trade and the other for industrial purposes.

Dice Physical Placement

In Cörpathium

In Cörpathium

When rolling the dice, you rolled them all at once and in a constrained space, on a piece of paper. Draw a rough circle around each die, and extend a line from the point of ‘each triangle’ on each die to see if it intersects another die. If it does, draw a line between the circles of the two dice.

I’m borrowing a picture from Logan’s most excellent In Cörpathium post to show what this looks like, kind of. You can see the dice used, the physical arrangement, and the lines drawn between them. He doesn’t show circles drawn around the dice but I find they’ll be useful when moving this to another medium.

From here we can fall back on the previous steps of assigning settlement scores, allocating points to the ward qualities (we now know what wards are present, where they are, and some of the connections between them), and so on.

Closing Comments

This process makes it easy to quickly assemble a toolkit that can be used to design settlements with a consistency you might expect to see in a strong, distinctive culture. There will be elements common across many settlements, with variation within that to keep them from being too homogeneous.

Logan’s dice drop mechanism makes it easy to determine how the various wards are placed and how they connect to each other. The connections might be physical (gates in walls, bridges over water), social (the ward of higher artisans provides services and crafting only to the nobility, while the ward of crafters serves the rest of the city), or other. Sometimes the dice placement will suggest things about the settlement (this particular ward is well away from the others, is that because it is full of pariahs and other social outcasts? Or is it just located on an island in the middle of the bay?).

Sadly, I don’t have time to work up an example right now (lunch break ends in a few minutes). If I were to do so, based on the example of Port Elren I might devise a culture with the Mercantile quality highest priority, then Skill (Craft) and Industrial, with Fortified and Religious somewhere around the middle (Port Elren does after all have a Fortified ward, despite having only three wards altogether). This could mean that most settlements generated under this mechanism would have one or more wards with Mercantile and Industrial wards (and possibly Mercantile/Industrial, if they’re paired on faces), while only the larger places might have major Religious wards.

Off the Path: City Construction, Part 3: Wards

So far, the city construction process has really only covered fairly homogeneous settlements. You might describe a bustling port as having lots of commerce (high Trade score and the Mercantile property) but highly-transient population that can get pretty rowdy (low Stability score). This isn’t a lot of detail, but until you need more it can be enough.

When you do need more, though, it’s possible to take a closer look.

Historically, many cities are actually made up of smaller pieces referred to as wards, districts, quarters, boroughs, neighborhoods… you get the idea. Each has its own characteristics that differentiate it from the others. Sometimes they grow over time, with the city expanding outside its walls or other barriers (such across a river) and then incorporating the new growth again. In other cases (such as the Seven Hills of Rome) several smaller settlements might grow until they merge together into a single, larger settlement.

The city construction guidelines make it easy to implement either of these.

Multi-Ward Settlements

It is very easy to split a settlement into wards, simply by dividing the population into smaller pieces and treating each as its own settlement with its own qualities. The settlement as a whole retains the same base settlement scores and level adjustment (if needed). Each ward has its own level adjustment and can assign the base scores differently.

Each settlement can have up to three qualities, plus one more at levels 13, 17, and every four levels after that. The settlement can assign a number of ranks up to the settlement’s level to these qualities. These ranks don’t need to be split evenly, but no quality should get more than half the ranks available (rounded up).

Each ward can have up to three qualities, and a number of ranks allocated to them equal to half the ward’s level, rounded up. Again, no more than half the ranks (rounded up) can be assigned to a single quality. The qualities of the wards should reflect those of the settlement as a whole (if you have a Mercantile quality for the settlement, at least one ward should have the Mercantile quality).

Port Elren

Port Elren is a small town (level 9, nominal population 283) at the mouth of the River Elre, where there are some modest docks that actually do more business than might be expected — possibly because of the crafters (tanners?) on the other side of the river. It has base scores of 16, 7, 13, 8, 11, 8, and I’ll assign them to Trade, Stability, Military, Social, Craft, and Infrastructure respectively:

  • Military 13 (+1)
  • Trade 16 (+3)
  • Infrastructure 7 (-2): I suspect the tanners are a bit upstream of the town proper
  • Craft 11 (+0)
  • Stability 8 (-1): pretty rowdy, lots of transients and ne’er-do-wells.
  • Social 8 (-1): lots of dives and cheap entertainment, not so much of the elites and whatnot.

Being a level 9 settlement, it’s grown and improved a bit, and gets a +2 modifier to all its scores:

  • Military 15 (+2)
  • Trade 18 (+4)
  • Infrastructure 9 (-1): things are cleaned up a bit, the roads are no longer paved in sewage, etc… still subject to some problems here, though.
  • Craft 13 (+1)
  • Stability 10 (+0): enough money and trade happen now that a city watch has been formed.
  • Social 10 (+0): some money has come in, and this is no longer quite as much a backwater.

As a level 9 settlement there are three qualities. Let’s say Trade, Military, and Industrial. This is primarily a trade town, with lesser emphasis on craft (local but valuable trade goods) and defense (fortification):

  • Mercantile IV (+4 to various checks relating to Trade and other connections);
  • Industrial III (+3 to checks relating to Craft and other ‘can we make it?’ questions);
  • Fortified II (+2 to checks related to Military defense and the like).

Altogether this tells me actually quite a bit about the settlement. I’ll still want to work up what the numbers mean specifically, especially with regard to player concerns (+8 to many Trade checks sounds like there should be a good market for valuable stuff like recovered treasure), but even so I’ve got a relative sense of things.

Port Elren, Multiple Wards

I’ve got a high-level view of Port Elren, but it looks like the PCs are going to hang around for a while. I’d like to get some greater detail.

It looks like I’ve got three major centres to the settlement: the fort, the market and docks, and the crafters. I’ll create three wards.

  • The mercantile ward is largest, so I’ll make it level 8.
  • The crafters is the next biggest, even if they’re on the other side of the river (so presumably there is at least one bridge), I’ll call that ward level 5.
  • The fort on the hill might have been quite important at one time, but is now almost an afterthought, so I’ll call that ward level 3.

The level 9 population (nominally 283 people) is now split between three wards of levels 8, 5, and 3 (nominal populations 200, 71, and 35 respectively, with modifiers of +2, +1, and +0 to all ability scores respectively). Because I’ve split these up, I’ve decided to use the same base scores but arrange them differently.

Score Settlement Scores Mercantile Ward (+2) Crafter Ward (+1) Military Ward (+0)
Military 15 (+3) 13+2 = 15 (+2) 8+1 = 9 (-1) 16 (+3)
Trade 18 (+4) 16+2 = 18 (+4) 8+1 = 9 (-1) 7 (-2)
Infrastructure 9 (-1) 11+2 = 13 (+1) 11+1 = 12 (+1) 13 (+1)
Craft 13 (+1) 7+2 = 9 (-1) 16+1 = 17 (+3) 8 (-1)
Stability 10 (+0) 8+2 = 10 (+0) 13+1 = 14 (+2) 11 (+0)
Social 10 (+0) 8+2 = 10 (+0) 7+1 = 8 (-1) 8 (-1)

Still not a lot of great night life around here. Each ward is better than the others at something, and these are largely reflected in the settlement scores as a whole. I see some differences between the settlement as a whole and all the wards. That the settlement’s Infrastructure as a whole is lower than the individual wards might mean I should change the score assignments for the settlement (swap Social and Infrastructure, say), or I could interpret it as a distinct lack of cooperation between the districts.

If I’d stuck with my original plan where all wards use the same base scores this wouldn’t happen. I might amend this so that if I do rearrange the scores, the settlement score must be equal to or greater than the lowest matching score among the wards. In all cases the settlement as a whole should be at least as strong — have a score no worse than — the weakest of its wards.

The qualities are pretty straightforward. Each ward can have up to three qualities.

  • Mercantile Ward is level 8, which means it can assign four ranks to qualities, no more than two to any one quality. Obviously gets Mercantile II (+2 to Trade checks, among other things), and I’ll assign Patrollers I (+1 to Stability) and Wealth I.
  • Crafter Ward is level 5, which means it can assign 3 ranks to qualities, no more than two to any quality. Craft (Leather) II (+2 to Craft checks) represents the fine leathers and leather products produced locally, and Industrial I suggests there’s a fair bit of other production done here.
  • Military Ward is level 3, which means it can assign 2 ranks to qualities, no more than 1 to any quality. There’s a decrepit old fort (Fortified I) and a small temple to the god of war (Religious I).

This is a higher-detail view of Port Elren than I started with, and I’m getting a better feel for the nature of the place. It’s a dirty industrial port town, still pretty rowdy in places, but busy and accumulating quite a coin for someone.

I don’t know that I’d go to this level of detail for a town that I’m not expecting to use a lot, but I think there is some potential for this to be useful when developing a town the PCs are likely to be around for a while.

The next post in this series makes a big step, from the local scene to nation-wide.

Off the Path: City Construction, Part 2: Qualities

In my last post I talked about the basics of city construction. Settlements have

  • settlement scores analogous to characters’ ability scores, though applied to different purpose;
  • levels analogous to character levels, that influence the size and resources available;
  • population analogous to experience points (which will come into play more in the next article);
  • qualities that expand on and help provide texture for the settlement.

In this post I’m going to talk more about qualities.

Settlement Qualities

The Pathfinder GameMastery Guide defines a dozen qualities that influence the nature of a settlement. Each quality is basically binary (present or not) and has a fixed effect. For instance, the ‘Academic’ quality indicates that “the settlement possesses a school, training facility, or university of great renown. (Lore +1, increase spellcasting by 1 level)”, where ‘Lore’ is a score that “measures not only how willing the citizens are to chat and talk with visitors, but also how available and accessible its libraries and sages are”, and ‘spellcasting’ affects the highest-level spells available for purchase or hire in the settlement.

I’m not using the same scores as the Pathfinder GameMastery Guide, so obviously I can’t use the same qualities the same way.

Measuring Qualities

Binary qualities are easily applied and adjudicated, but I am leaning away from that. I think I’d rather see them quantitative, with different values, so I don’t have to define ‘Fortified I’, ‘Fortified II’, and ‘Fortified III’ qualities. I’d rather see ‘Fortified’ with a value of 3 than need three qualities.

Off the top of my head (I haven’t formalized a list) I think I’ll have qualities such as

  • Fortified adds to Military modifier on rolls against attacks. This quality probably looks like a palisade or earthen ramparts or stone walls, choke points in approaches to the settlement (probably with guard posts), siege engines, and so on.
  • Religious might add to Stability checks, but I can imagine examples where it might not. A primary benefit, though, comes in having divine support for the settlement. This quality might indicate a large temple or collection of temples, religious icons commonly displayed, and so on.
  • Mercantile adds to Trade modifier on certain checks. This quality probably indicates many or large marketplaces, caravansaries, dockyards, guilds, and other locations to trade or means of transportation.
  • Industrial could add to Craft (more people working to make stuff) or Trade (more goods to export)… or I could see a couple more possibilities. It might not even add to any checks, instead providing other benefits. I need to think about this. In any case, it probably looks like more crafters, or improved manufacturing resources such as mills and factories.
  • Wealthy would probably add to one or both of Trade and Social checks, depending on the origin of the wealth. The houses are nicer, people tend to be better-dressed, and so on.
  • Resources (needs a better name) would add to Infrastructure checks, and indicates things like storehouses to hold food, aqueducts to ensure good water, and so on.
  • Academic is probably like Religious in that it might not actually add to any checks, but provide support for skills within the city, especially Knowledge or Profession skills. As might be expected, a settlement with the Academic quality probably has schools and colleges and the like.
  • (Skill) indicates that the skill, or rather those that practice it, are easier to find than might otherwise be the case, or more capable than might be expected. This could interact with Religious, Industrial, and/or Academic. For instance, while you can reasonably expect to find an armorer in most cities of a certain size, the Craft (Armorer) quality indicates that more or better armorers are found here than usual. This probably looks a lot like Industrial, except that it should be evident which skill is the focus of the quality. Also, it is probably easy to see the results (products or services) of the skill available for sale.

As I said above, each of these would likely have a numeric value indicating ‘how much’ effect the quality has. This value might be added to specific checks as needed, and in some cases is just a measure. ‘Craft (Weaponsmith) I’ might mean common weapons are readily available for sale, while ‘Craft (Weaponsmith) II’ might mean uncommon weapons or masterwork weapons are readily available — no check needed, they just are.

The list needs to be developed further, but this should give a sense of what qualities are, what they do, and how they might influence the appearance of a settlement.

Off the Path: City Construction, Part 1: Basics

Deviating from plan (I’d said my next post would be about building a ‘local pantheon’ of small gods), I decided to write instead about alternate rules for developing a city or other settlement.

It expands somewhat on the Polyhedral Pantheons Adaptations I wrote about a while ago.

Settlement Basics

Before diving into process, I’m going to describe some of the mechanical underpinnings. They are in some ways pretty similar to how characters are created.

Settlement Scores

Each settlement has ability scores comparable to — and associated with — the normal character ability scores.

Settlement Score Ability Score Description
Military Strength How well the settlement can deal with military and other active threats.
Trade Dexterity How much commerce is done and how well-connected the settlement is to other entities.
Infrastructure Constitution How resilient and enduring the settlement is in physical terms; includes actual infrastructure such as roads and aqueducts, and availability of important resources such as food and healing.
Craft Intelligence How much artifice, creation, and innovation are available in the settlement.
Stability Wisdom How well-regulated the settlement is, especially in the face of disruption.
Social Charisma How active and sophisticated social elements of the settlement are.

Generate these through the normal means: point buy, random roll, whatever. I favor adapting ‘27-25-23‘, making it instead ’23-21-19’:

  • Roll 3d6, subtract from 23. These are two scores.
  • Roll 3d6, subtract from 21. These are two more scores.
  • Roll 3d6, subtract from 19. These are two more scores.
  • (reroll anything that would result in a score outside 3..18)
  • Assign to taste.

I like that all settlements start with some difficulties. These will be overcome as they get larger (see below) and generally aren’t crippling anyway.

Settlement Levels

Level Qualities Population GMG size Low Pop High Pop
1 1 18 thorp       15 21
2 1 25 thorp 21 30
3 1 35 hamlet 30 42
4 1 50 hamlet 42 59
5 2 71 village 59 84
6 2 100 village 84 119
7 2 141 village 119 168
8 2 200 village 168 238
9 3 283 small town 238 336
10 3 400 small town 336 476
11 3 566 small town 476 673
12 3 800 small town 673 951
13 4 1,131 small town 951 1,345
14 4 1,600 small town 1,345 1,903
15 4 2,263 large town 1,903 2,691
16 4 3,200 large town 2,691 3,805
17 5 4,525 large town 3,805 5,382
18 5 6,400 small city 5,382 7,611
19 5 9,051 small city 7,611 10,763
20 5 12,800 large city 10,763 15,222
21 6 18,102 large city 15,222 21,527
22 6 25,600 metropolis 21,527 30,444
23 6 36,204 metropolis 30,444 43,054
24 6 51,200 metropolis 43,054 60,887
25 7 72,408 metropolis 60,887 86,108

Like characters, settlements have levels. Small, minor settlements (thorps and hamlets and whatnot) are very low-level, major settlements such as large cities and metropolises are high-level. This affects how good a settlement is at something, and the population.

At levels 4, 8, and every fourth level after that, add 1 point to all six settlement scores.

I’m going to say that a level 2 settlement has a population of about 25 people, and that every two levels the population doubles. Increasing or decreasing by one level multiplies the nominal population by the square root of 2 (about 1.4).

The exact populations aren’t particularly important, so I’m looking at ‘nominal population’ to provide an estimate.

The ‘GMG Size’ column assigns settlement type, per the Pathfinder Roleplaying Game: GameMastery Guide guidelines… approximately. This actually will have little direct impact on the process mechanically, but is useful for descriptive purposes.

When assigning the ‘GMG Size’ values I looked at the nominal population rather than the population range. For example, a level 8 settlement has a nominal population of 200. Per Pathfinder Roleplaying Game: GameMastery Guide a settlement with a population of 201 is a ‘small town’. It would seem that this would fit the level 8 settlement because 201 lands in the level 8 population range (168..238)… but I chose to not do that.

Population and Experience Points

Population of a settlement grows on an exponential scale. Every two levels the population nominally (it’s not likely to be exact) doubles.

By strange coincidence — no, really, it wasn’t planned on my part — the experience point totals needed in the Pathfinder Roleplaying Game to advance levels doubles every two levels. (Or rather, the series converges on that ratio, more or less, once you get past about 10th level… but it works for slow, medium, and fast rates.)

So it looks like population and experience points have similar enough curves that for this purpose they can basically be equated. This leads to all sorts of interesting ideas for city-building minigames that I’m not thinking about too hard right now. But I will remember for later.

Settlement Qualities

A settlement has ‘qualities’ that modify the nature of the settlement. In some cases a quality might provide a modifier to a settlement score (‘defensible’ indicates that the settlement is easier to defend from attack than most, providing a bonus to the Military score). In other cases a quality might indicate a specific resource or other benefit to the settlement.

These can be similar in concept to the Settlement Qualities described in the Pathfinder Roleplaying Game: GameMastery Guide guidelines, but as these rules use different scores they would have different effect.

My next post on city construction will cover qualities in greater detail.

Black Friday and White Star Dent Removal Sale

James Spahn (Barrel Rider Games, publisher of White Star and of Labyrinth Lord supplements) had an unfortunate interaction with a kamikaze bambi. He and his family are fine, nobody in the car was injured, but they’re looking at a big repair bill.

I was already planning to run a sale this weekend, but it’s changed a bit. From now through Cyber Monday, all Echelon Game Design products — Polyhedral PantheonsDraconic Bloodlines, and the entire Echelon Reference Series — are on sale at a 20% discount. Half my proceeds will go to James to get the bambi-shaped dents and other damage to his car fixed.

Off the Path: Small Gods

Many campaigns have world-spanning deities whose power reaches everywhere (more or less). They can provide the ‘full range of services’ (i.e. spells all the way up to ninth level, or seventh in some editions of D&D). Very useful from a game play perspective.

However, the idea of being able to meet and interact (and deal) with the actual spirit of the forest has always intrigued me. I like the idea of divine creatures who have notable power but are greatly limited in their reach.

It turns out this is pretty easy to do in the Pathfinder Roleplaying Game.

Making a Small God

The simplest mechanical implementation of small gods is to simply use (and bend slightly) the mythic rules.

  • A small god is a creature of at least CR 5, and typically at least Mythic Rank 3. The creature gains:
    • the mythic subtype;
    • a bonus to natural armor (base +0 if it doesn’t otherwise have natural armor) equal to its MR;
    • bonus hit points equal to its MR times 6, 8, or 10, depending on whether the base creature uses d6, d8, or (d10 or d12) as its racial Hit Die;
    • damage reduction (5/epic if it has 5 to 10 Hit Dice, 10/epic if it has 11 or more Hit Dice; existing DR if any is merged);
    • bonus to spell resistance equal to MR, if it has spell resistance;
    • the mythic power and mythic surge universal monster abilities;
    • at MR 2, 4, 6, 8, and 10, the creature gains a +2 bonus to one ability score (all can be added to one score or they can be split up);
    • at MR 1, 3, 5, 7, and 9, the creature gains a mythic feat it qualifies for;
    • additional mythic abilities equal to one more than its MR;
    • CR increased by half the MR, XP adjusted to match.
  • Among the mythic abilities, pick
    • Divine Source (Su): [3rd-Tier Universal Path Ability] The creature can grant divine spells to those who follow its cause. Choose two domains suitable to the small god’s portfolio/interests. The small god can only grant spells of a level up to its MR. The small god can cast one spell per spell level per day, chosen from the domain spells available. At MR 6 and MR 9 this mythic ability can be taken again, adding one domain and two subdomains. Deviation from RAW: the small god does not need to take ‘alignment domains first’, per the normal mythic ability. A subdomain may be chosen in place of a domain if it better suits the small god.
  • The small god might have other divine casting ability, such as (and probably no more than) one of:
    • the Simple Divine Spellcasting ability (universal monster rule), giving it knowledge of cleric or druid spells with a total number of levels equal to twice its Hit Dice (none higher than 1.5 times its Hit Dice) and the ability to cast each once per day;
    • the Cleric Creature template from Pathfinder Roleplaying Game: Monster Codex;
    • cleric (or druid, etc.) levels.
  • The small god might also have the Mythic Magic ability (universal monster rule). Three times per day when it casts a spell (from Divine Source or Simple Divine Spellcasting or some other ability) it can spend mythic power to cast the spell as a mythic spell.

Fill in the rest of the abilities and you should be about done.

Note that you could use the Divine mythic simple template instead, but I think the more detailed rebuild works better.

Sample Small God: Sheshsia, the Well Spirit

The farmers and other villagers of the valley perform small rituals to thank Sheshsia, the Well Spirit, for keeping their water clean and sweet.

Mechanically — I’ll expand on her story elements in another post — Sheshsia is a mythic huge water elemental (CR 10/MR 4) with the Divine Source (Water and Community domains) mythic ability and the cleric creature template (normally +2, but I discounted to +1 for weak spell choices and because the stats aren’t CR 11).

Huge Water Elemental
CR 10/MR 4 (base CR 7, template is +2, MR is +2, but much closer to in-line with CR 10 because many of the added abilities are weak)
XP 12,800
N Huge outsider (elemental, extraplanar, mythic, water)
Init +8; Senses darkvision 60 ft.; Perception +17

AC 25, touch 13, flat-footed 20 (+4 Dex, +1 dodge, +12 natural, –2 size)
hp 135 (10d10+40+40)
Fort +11, Ref +11, Will +7
DR 5/—; Immune elemental traits

Speed 20 ft., swim 90 ft.
Melee 2 slams +15 (2d6+7)
Space 15 ft.; Reach 15 ft.
Special Attacks channel energy (3/day, level 8), drench, mythic power (4/day, surge +1d8), vortex (DC 22), water mastery
Cleric Domain Spells (CL 10th; DC 14+level)
4th (1/day)—imbue with spell abilitysleet storm
3rd (1/day)—call lightningprayer
2nd (1/day)—fog cloudshield other
1st (1/day)—blessobscuring mist
Cleric Spells (CL 10th; DC 14+level)
4th—control water
3rd—remove diseasewater breathing (might have remove curse instead of water breathing)
2nd—cure moderate woundslesser restoration
1st—(any two)
0—(any two, often create water or purify food and drink)
Mythic Abilities amazing initiative (+4), divine source (Community, Water), empathic healing, hard to kill, pure body, recuperation, water of life

Str 24, Dex 18, Con 19, Int 6, Wis 19, Cha 11
Base Atk +10; CMB +19; CMD 34
Feats Cleave, DodgeM, Great Cleave, Improved Bull Rush, Power AttackM
Skills Acrobatics +11, Escape Artist +15, Knowledge (planes) +7, Perception +17, Stealth +3, Swim +26

In practice I would be inclined to change the domain spells, such as by creating a new subdomain or hybrid domain. The water domain as written doesn’t quite align with what I want here. I added the ‘cleric creature’ simple template to provide additional spell access that better fit what I wanted. Because the spells typically don’t have combat utility and the statistics align more closely to a CR 9 creature than to a CR 11 creature, I’m treating this as a CR 10 creature — the additional spells and channel energy clearly add something, but it’s not as much as might be suggested by the template.

Closing Comments

Creating the statistics for Sheshsia, the Well Spirit, was mostly straightforward. There was some slight complication when I found the domain spells didn’t do quite what I wanted, but it wasn’t that hard to work around. In practice I’d do more, probably create a ‘Sheshsia domain’ that replaced some of the water spells with something that better fit my vision.

Those who entreat Sheshia for divine power gain access to cleric spells, but only of up to fourth level. She is neutral, but I would consider her to have good tendencies and thus require that her clerics channel positive energy. Those who can plead their case to her directly might benefit from her abilities… but they’re pretty limited.

My next post will focus somewhat on how to build a ‘local pantheon’ of small gods.

Off the Path: HERO Power Construction

A brief diversion on the Words of Power exploration, I thought it worth providing a bit of an overview of how powers are constructed in HERO System. This looks like it will become important soon.


Powers in HERO are based on effect, with descriptors added to give flavor and something to hook abilities on. At its root, a fireball and a lightning bolt are very similar: they do damage at range. In HERO 6e terms, and for the sake of argument, they both use the Blast power (previous editions it was ‘Energy Blast’, but the same power was used for energy and physical blasts. Blast costs 5 points per 1d6 damage, and has a range directly proportional to points. The descriptors provide narrative and descriptive elements that can be applied, and can influence how these interact with other powers. For instance, a staff that augments fire powers can make the fireball more powerful, but do nothing for the lightning bolt. For this example, we’ll work with an 8d6 blast in both cases (worth 40 points, the Base Cost).

That is at the base… but powers are not just the base effect. In this case ‘fireball’ implies that it fills a circular area, while a lightning bolt probably zaps anything between where the bolt started and where it ends. The fireball might be best defined as having a ‘radius area of effect’ that determines how much gets charred, and the lightning bolt could be defined as having a ‘line area of effect’. This sounds like it should make the spells better than without, providing an advantage. It would be reasonable to expect this to be more expensive… and it is.


The 40 point base cost is just where we start. Advantages are measured in units of “+¼” (and presented in simple form: the next step up from a +¼ advantage is a +½ advantage, not a +2/4 advantage). You  multiply the base cost by (1+sum of advantages) to get the Active Cost, the measure of how powerful the power is. A 4d6 Blast (20 Base Cost) with +1 of advantages would have an Active Cost of 40, same as the 8d6 Blast (and in principle is as powerful — it might do less base damage, but the advantages might make it better than the 8d6 Blast, such as if it were armor piercing and able to ignore some armor, or indirect and not needing line of effect to the target).

In the Pathfinder Roleplaying Game, fireball has a 20-foot radius. This doesn’t align exactly with HERO System (which uses metric on a hex grid, each hex being 2 metres across), but 20 feet is four squares, and if I equate that to four hexes that would be 8 metres. In reality this is a little more than 25 feet, but in game terms I’ll consider this a rounding error. A power in HERO with an 8-metre radius would have a “+¾” advantage. The fireball has an Active Cost of 40*(1+¾)= 70 points.

With the lightning bolt I’m going to do something different. In the Pathfinder Roleplaying Game this is a 120-foot line, but instead I’m going to make it indirect, a +½ advantage that means I don’t need line of effect to my target. Unlike the fireball I affect only a single target, but I all lightning from the sky to strike my enemies, and don’t need to be able to reach them directly. The indirect advantages increases my Active Cost to (40*(1+½)=) 60 points, but ‘calling lightning from the sky’ sounds like I need to be able to see the sky. That limits how I can use the spell, it’s not going to be much use underground.


Limitations serve two purposes in power construction. They lower the Real Cost of a power to make it affordable (in a Heroic-grade game a 60- or 70-point power would consume a very large fraction of a character’s build resources), they provide restrictions on the use of a power to make the powers more interesting to play, and they help make the powers more distinct.

As advantages, limitations are measured in units of ¼, but are marked as negative values as a reminder. Where the Base Cost is multiplied by (1+advantages) to get the Active Cost, the Active Cost is divided by (1+absolute value of limitations). That is, a 60 Active Cost power with -½ limitation would be worth 60/(1+½)= 40 character points.

In the Pathfinder Roleplaying Game, casting fireball has verbal, somatic, and material components. In HERO terms these would be Incantations (verbal utterance for the purpose of activating power and no other purpose, recognizable as unusual; preventing speech prevents the power from being used: -¼), Gestures (free and visible movement for the purpose of activating power and no other purpose, recognizable as unusual; preventing free movement prevents the power from being used, -¼), and a Focus (“Obvious Accessible Focus”: it’s clear that the bat guano and sulphur are used for unusual purpose, and thus ‘obvious’, they can be knocked out of hand (spoiling the spell) with a single action, and thus ‘accessible’, -1… foci are worth a lot in HERO). This is a total of -1½ limitation. This reduces the Real Cost to (70/(1+1½)=) 28 character points. Still awfully big for a heroic-grade HERO campaign, but you wouldn’t often see a starting PC with a 70 Active Point spell.

The lightning bolt, on the other hand, requires some more adjudication. There actually isn’t an inherent “must be able to see the sky” limitation, so the GM will need to determine a limitation value based on campaign expectation. If the campaign is largely set outdoors, this might be only a -¼ limitation: the sky is almost always available. If the campaign is in the Underdark and the sky is only rarely visible it might be -1½ (or even more! and this is probably a silly spell to pick). I’m going to guess here and say that the spell is usable roughly half the time, which is a -1 limitation (and I’ll be strict — if I made it a -½ limitation I’d likely still let it work in caves and rooms with windows, as long as the sky was reachable). I’m going to say that this spell has verbal and somatic components (-½ together), but that each casting consumes a wand made from the branch of a lightning-struck oak (OAF expendable, hard to get: -1¼). This gives a Real Cost of (60/(1+1.75)=) 21.8181… points — which in HERO rounds down to 21 points to 22 points.

Thanks to Chakat for the correction, I was misremembering a different example. Rounding in HERO is to the nearest integer, with half-points being rounded in the character’s favor. The only exception I can find is that the figured SPEED attribute always truncates — a character with Dex 18 would make DEX checks at 13- (i.e. 9+18/5 = 12.6, rounds up to 13) and have a base SPD of 2.8 (1 + DEX/10), which gets treated as SPD 2 for determining actions.

Closing Comments

This has been a brief explanation of power construction in HERO System. Even just as far as I’ve gone here, the flexibility inherent in the system should be evident… and I left out some of the funkier options, such as:

  • Naked advantages, advantages bought ‘as powers’ that can be applied to other powers. Buy an advantage as its own power, such as being able to Autofire ‘any weapon’ up to a certain Active Cost: take the Active cost of the biggest effect the Autofire can be used with, multiply by the Autofire advantage cost, and treat the result as the base cost of the ‘Autofire power’.
  • Partially-limited powers, where you can apply limitations to some but not all of a power. For instance, the 8d6 ‘fireball’ above has Gestures, Incantations, and OAF limitations. The spell could be written as being 6d6 with those limitations but having 4d6 more power available if other limitations (such as Extra Endurance, Extra Time and Concentration, say) are applied. You can cast a 6d6 fireball ‘normally’, or exert yourself (Extra Endurance, Extra Time, and Concentration) to cast a 10d6 fireball. The Active and Real costs of the two pieces would be calculated and added together to find the final values for the spell.
  • Power frameworks, where thematically related powers are grouped together to reduce their Real cost. This gives you more powers available at once, but there are restrictions on how you can use them. For instance, a ‘multipower laser rifle’ might have several ‘configurations’ that allow you to use Blast, Killing Attack, each with Autofire or Armor Piercing or Area of Effect… but only one configuration at a time. Lots of options, cheaper than getting six different items, but only one is usable at a time.

Hopefully this will help make my next Words of Power articles easier to understand. I’m pretty sure I can lean on this power construction mechanism to build and apply the Words of Power framework I’m devising.

Letters from the Flaming Crab Kickstarter

Alex Abel — the Flaming Crab himself — is Kickstarting the 2017 Letters from the Flaming Crab series.

These are small (15-20 page), flavorful supplements that explore topics often overlooked in many roleplaying games, topics that help round out a setting and make it more than a murderhobo arena.

Topics from 2016 include:

  • Winged Cavalry Welcome to our first issue: Winged Cavalry! Our team of writers brings you the master of aerial combat: the wind warden, an alternate class for the cavalier. And 4 orders for the wind warden: the order of the feather (pegasus), order of the hunt (pteranodon), order of the spire (magic carpet), and the order of talon and mane (griffon). In addition, we have a few advanced flying maneuvers in the book. “Do a barrel roll!”
  • Culinary Magic Within Culinary Magic you’ll find rules for culinary magic, a variety of recipes, new items, feats, and traits for magical bakers and chefs, and two new archetypes: the kitchen witch and the performing chef.
  • Haunted Places Within Haunted Places, you’ll find four haunts (one is sometimes also a loci), one new medium spirit, and three new archetypes inspired by those haunts just in time for the spookiest day of the year.
  • Wheel of the Year Wheel of the Year features 9 pagan holidays, from Yule to Samhain!For each holiday we have a brief description, the types of deities that are revered, mystic resonances (each holiday has a school of magic that’s enhanced and one that’s weakened), and a specific ritual/spell that may be cast during these events. Without celebrations, a campaign world is a sterile place. Breathe some life into your game with holidays!
  • Iconic Princesses Iconic Princesses features 4 women from classic fairy tales ready to be introduced into your campaign as NPCs or even as PCs.Each “princess” is detailed in the established iconic format (1st, 7th, and 12th level) along with a unique magic item, feat, or spell. Inside you’ll find:
    • Beauty. A vengeful witch that protects the powerless and curses their oppressors.
    • Mulan. A resourceful brawler that defends her homeland in her father’s stead.
    • Rapunzel. A disciplined monk with a hardened mind and barbed hair.
    • Snow White. A wandering occultist with a zest for battle.
  • Here There Be (tiny) Dragons Here There Be (tiny) Dragons presents six new Tiny sized dragons to be used as friend, foe, or improved familiar! It also features new archetypes and a new class of scaling wondrous item, dragonstones, that can only be used by a dragon and non-dragon in cooperation!
  • Her Story In honor of Women’s History Month, Her Story tells the tales of 8 incredible women (from Earth). It also features “crunch” inspired by each woman. (For example, Saint Clare Assisi inspired a pious Inquisitor archetype and 5 new virtues.) Inside you’ll find:
    • Countess Elizabeth Báthory de Ecsed
    • Queen Boudicca
    • Saint Clare of Assisi
    • Doctor Marie Curie
    • Hatshepsut
    • Joan of Arc
    • Osh-Tisch
    • Mary Shelley
  • Coins & Credit Within Coins and Credit (our biggest Letter, yet!), we cover the topic of money and how to make it fit in your campaign (and your bag of holding).
    The first part of our 8th Letter is all about coins. We cover mundane and magical currency crafting, counterfeiting, coin size, exchange rates, and transportation of coins. Slaying the dragon is great and all, but how many coins can you fit in a leather bag? And is the party barbarian strong enough to carry the whole hoard? Part two is on banks. Surely you don’t want to lug around all that gold? Even if you got it converted to mithral pieces, tens of thousands of metal coins is a lot for our heroes! We cover the different types of banks, account types, loans, account tiers, the likelihood of finding banks in different settlements, and example banks!Finally, part three covers credit. Don’t worry if your head is still spinning from tax season. We make things simple for you and your adventuring party! We cover tabs, letters of credit, promissory notes, banknotes, and magic items to assist in the transfer of wealth!
  • Hygiene In the days of old, the public bathhouse was as much of a social center as any tavern. So why not mix things up and start your adventure somewhere a little more clean? Sure, the half-orc may object to soapy water (after all, he’d get a -2 penalty on Diplomacy checks against his own people for being dishonorably cleansed of his enemy’s blood), but I’m sure the elf noble wouldn’t object to spending time in a more refined and relaxing establishment.Within Hygiene, we cover both the effects of neglecting cleanliness and places where you can scrub after delving in a mucky dungeon! Included are maps for each of the 6 locations inside, including 3 bathhouses (Japanese, Roman, meditative), a barber shop, laundry pools, and a salon.
  • County Faire Within County Faire, we take a trip to the fantastic Fantasia County Faire! It’s the perfect location to take a break from dragon slaying and dungeon delving! There is plenty to do!Play a variety of games of skill and chance! Can you hold your alcohol like a dwarf during the chug run? How many hot peppers can you handle in the flame mouth competition?See one of a kind spectacles and events! The finest cows, goats, sheep, and pigs are on display at the livestock contest! Watch a variety of animal races, everything from horses to humans to rats!Between events, be sure to pick up delectable treats. The faire has anything and everything you crave (most of it is fried, of course)! Children and adults with a sweet tooth will especially love dropping by Sugar’s Sweets!We’ve also included a mini adventure for 1st or 2nd level characters! The PCs are employed by the fireworks specialist– the Splendiferous Spranza– to guard her tent from nosy locals and mischievous children. While the default setting is the Fantasia County Faire, it can be used at any faire, festival, or celebration.
  • Inspired by Heraldry Within Inspired by Heraldry…We bring you 5 new unusual creatures for Pathfinder that are often featured as decorations upon a shield of arms: biscoine, enfield, lepus hositili (murder bunny), talbot hound, and yale.We also introduce heraldic feats that allow characters to draw power from their noble bloodline, familial history, and the spiritual patron of their clan. We feature the following patrons: allocamelus, basilisk, bear, biscoine, boar, bull, dragon, enfield, griffin, lepus hostili, manticore, phoenix, serpent, talbot hound, toad, unicorn, and yale.And we finish Inspired by Heraldry with the heraldic knight, an alternate class for the cavalier that invokes the power of their family’s crest.
  • Strange Weather Within Strange Weather…We bring you a dozen new Conditions and Hazards more magical and exciting than a mere thunderstorm! Acid rain, aurora hypnosis, ball lightning, blood storm, ectoplasmic storm, fire whirl, hailstorm, pollen storm, skyquake, blood moon, dread moon, radiant moon, and the solar eclipse!We also introduce the Storm Elemental with four variants: the blizzard storm elemental, dust storm elemental, hurricane elemental, and lightning storm elemental!And we finish Strange Weather with two weather related archetypes: the Stormcaller (Shaman) and the Child of the Sky (Barbarian)!
  • Dinosaur Companions We introduce 25 new dinosaurs (and pterosaurs and a crocodilian) to choose from to be your new best friend! Every dinosaur can be an animal companion/mount or familiar!15 of these prehistoric pals are animal companions/mounts: Argentinosaurus, Baryonyx, Concavenator, Corythosaurus, Deinocherius, Dilophosaurus, Dracorex, Excaliborsaurus, Maiasaura, Neptunidraco, Scipionyx, Stygimoloch, Tethyshadros, Tupandactylus, and Utahraptor!10 of them are familiars: Coelophysis, Jinfengopteryx, Leaellynasaura, Mei, Micropachycephalosaurus, Microraptor, Nyctosaurus, Parvicursor, Scansoriopteryx, and Sordes!
  • Household Magic

In 2017 they plan to drop to bimonthly (i.e. every two months, not the misbegotten twice per month) in order to accommodate the request that they make each issue longer. Topics planned include:

  • The Puppet Show
  • Gremlins
  • Libraries and Research
  • Imaginary Friends
  • Religious Communities
  • Dangerous Spores
  • 3 personal letters (topics chosen by high-rolling backers)

If you’re interested in an eclectic mix of topics that can help you flesh out your world, I recommend you check this Kickstarter out and consider backing.

Tenkar’s Disclosure: Alex is a friend of mine online, I backed his Archetype Compendium, Echelon Explorations: Polyhedral Pantheons was an add-on for $30+ pledges for the Letters from the Flaming Crab (2016) Kickstarter last year, and we’ve been talking about my writing about Small Gods for one of the Letters.

Letters from the Flaming Crab (2017)

Letters from the Flaming Crab (2017)


Off the Path: Words of Power, Part 2

In my last post I outlined some things I’d like to see in the Words of Power system.

  1. Cost based on caster level;
  2. Reorganizing the effects;
  3. Unified power framework.

The unified power framework might seem to be the most ambitious… but I noticed something that might make it a lot less work than I expected. I’ll come back to that a little further below.

Examining Words of Power

Runecaster by Gary Dupuis

Runecaster by Gary Dupuis

Let’s start looking at aspects of the words of power and see where it takes us.


I’m going to use Healing Words as my starting point. In Words of Power there are five healing words that map more or less directly to the stabilize spell and the four cure wounds spells (soothing touch stabilizes a dying creature, then each level of Word after that heals 1d6+level (max 5*word level) points of damage — 1d8+1/level if the spell is boosted).

This is an okay starting point, but I want characters with greater word mastery to be able to get greater effect for cost. It doesn’t matter if you have elder cure (4d6+1/level, 4d8+1/level boosted) if you only use a second-level slot. Also, I really don’t like “per level” calculations in effects. I considered having the same degree of healing for a single point (so having Healing Word IV lets you do 4d6 points of healing for one magic point) but that’s way too rich if I’m going to allow using more than one point.

I’ll back it off. Healing Word I heals 1d6 points per magic point, Healing Word II heals 1d8 points per magic point (just 1 more on average), Healing Word III heals 1d10 points per magic point… and following my smoother damage progression, Healing Word IV and Healing Word V heal 2d6 and 2d8 points per magic point respectively. With the understanding that cantrips are often considered “half” a first-level spell, I’ll include a Healing Word 0 (cantrip-grade) for 1d3 points of healing per magic point.

But wait! 1d3… that’s… half a d6. And d6, then d8 has a mean of 4.5, which is d6+1, and d10 has a mean of 5.5 (or d6+2, or the same as d6+d3… one and a half d6s).

HERO System damage classes (DC) are five points each, and go 1, ½d6, 1d6, 1d6+1, 1½d6, 2d6, 2d6+1, 2½d6, 3d6… the Healing Word I spell does 1d6, Healing Word II does 1d8 and averages the same as 1d6+1, Healing Word III does 1d10 averages the same as 1½d6, Healing Word IV does 2d6, Healing Word V does 2d8 and averages… 9 points, one point higher than 2d6+1. Close enough. Even Healing Word 0 aligns, at 1d3 (½d6), and the (as-yet unmentioned) “Healing Word -1” (because Echelon has a Pre-Basic tier even below Basic tier, for things like rats) doing a single point of healing would align.

So… power words being worth 15 Active cost (in HERO terms) at tier 1, then plus or minus 5 Active cost per tier above or below, there must be something I can do with this. Let’s look at limitations, see how they line up.

Limitations on Words of Power

The Words of Power system expects that all spells have Verbal, Somatic, and Material components, unless otherwise indicated, and take a standard action to cast. The Verbal and Somatic components apply only when casting, and map directly to the Incantations and Gestures limitations, each at the -¼ level. Material components have no special cost, but are easily identifiable at casting time and taking them away is a relatively simple action. Together I’m going to call them an “Obvious Accessible Focus” (OAF), which is a -1 limitation. This gives a total limitation of -1½ on spells by default.

This works well for me. If power words have an Active Cost of 5 points per tier, and expected limitations of -1½, that means the power words have a Real Cost of 2 points (5/(1+1½) = 5/2½ = 2) per tier.

What if I ignore Active Cost here and look primarily at Real Cost? If I require that a power word is worth “2 Real” per tier and allow the Active Cost to swing, I find I could have more variety in the power of the words, with varying degrees of limitation. A ‘simple spell’ (low limitation, such as ‘just Verbal and Somatic components’, a total of -½) would limit the power word to 3 Active Cost per tier. Simple to cast, doesn’t do much. Or I could go the other way and increase the limitations (let’s say requiring more time to cast and spending more magic points — Extra Time and Extra Endurance in HERO terms) but get an effect with more Active Points — harder to cast, but more powerful. The -1½ already present on the spell means I’m not going to get a lot of mileage out of adding more limitations, though. To double the Active Points available (from 5 points per tier to 10 points per tier) I’m going to need to take the divisor from 2½ to 5 — which means increasing the limitations from -1½ to -4! That’s a huge jump, so this is not an easy path to incredible cosmic power.

It does, however, gain me something nifty.

Variations and Unified Casting

I don’t have to stick with Verbal, Somatic, and Material components (Incantations, Gestures, Focus). HERO provides me with all sorts of options for limitations that could be applied.

Concentration: made for a psychic/psionic system.

Requires Skill Check: want a skill-based magic system? Or just the ability to do crazy fantastic things with skill checks? Or…

… or even martial. ‘Sword Magic’ can be a thing! It might use attack rolls instead of skill checks, or not, but this could be a thing.

Aaand I need to get back to work, lunch break is over. I’ll have to continue this more later.